www.guideadvice.org by Mehnaz Amjad

All issues

Why do I change my opinions based on who I'm with ?


As a shy, introverted child, even though I grew up in a large joint family and an even larger extended family on my parents' side, I remained a loner most of my life.

My introduction to loneliness is as old as I am, and it goes back to the time when, amidst huge family gatherings and community events, I would feel lost.

Was I a case of non-inclusion, or did I deliberately choose solitude?

I guess it was the former for most of my young adult life my struggle was to find my way into the friends, cousins and relatives circle I was never allowed in; I was part of the circle but not the inner circle and everyone in my network seemed to have one. Then when I passed age 40 that I woke up to the beauty of a solitude of my own choosing.

The choosing: It was difficult for me to walk up to people and initiate a conversation and more difficult to partake in a conversation that holds no depth, for example, the gossip in the gatherings about how an aunt managed to purchase a designer saree despite her husband's income may not have left her with anything extra, because I didn't contribute much except for some nods and hums, my relatives stereotyped me as cold, distant and aloof. I was therefore politely excluded from the invisible inner circles and met with silence when I made futile attempts to find my way inside.

Keep reading

Enter your email to finish this story and get Mehnaz Amjad's next one straight to your inbox.

Already subscribed? Enter the same address and you'll go straight through. · Free, and you can unsubscribe any time.

Share

More issues

All 383 →
#382 Oct 13, 2026

How do I know If I'm people pleasing or just being considerate

Read issue →
#381 Oct 6, 2026

Why does disappointing people feel unbearable to me ?

Read issue →